bard_linn: Generic stand in icon for when I don't have one for whatever I'm talking about. (Zack x Sephiroth)
bard_linn ([personal profile] bard_linn) wrote2008-01-28 02:53 pm

Reaction from the latest chapter

Can I just say how amused I am about how people are reacting to BE32? Some people are like "OMG, ZackxSeph most evil thing ever you ruined the story for me!"....amazing how many of these people a) never reviewed before and (obviously) b) never looked at our profiles. Kiraya's got her pairings LISTED for Shiva's sake.

(Hm....Shiva. So pretty.)

I can think of one reviewer who figured out homosexuality would probably be included and asked. We told her/him that yes, it would be. I refuse to warn for homosexuality. Life is not going to pop up and say "WARNING. HOMOSEXUAL COUPLE AROUND THE CORNER."

We knew some people would react like that though. The REALLY amusing thing is the "OMG NOT CLOUD/TIFA I BEG YOU!!!!" reviews. Of course it feels a bit weird - Cloud has just decided to TRY it. They aren't going to turn into a couple overnight.

(And for the record - people STILL thinking it might end up Vin/Cloud get a clue stop hoping. It is a platonic, father/son relationship, kay?)

...and I really should compose a Real Life update, shouldn't I? *gets started*

[identity profile] elanor-pam.livejournal.com 2008-01-28 08:06 pm (UTC)(link)
...were there really reviews like that? XD;; I didn't see any like those on insanejournal, and here in lj there don't seem to be any like them either. I'm guessing they came from the pit...

Your real life example of homo warning cracks me up. XDD (I wish we had those for snogging couples, though. Seeing people kissing just embarasses the hell out of me. Like walking in on someone in the bath.)

And begging for no Zack/Seph or Cloud/Tifa? Without even reading where you intend to go with them? Nevermind my own pairing preferences - I don't really care about Sephiroth, but I'm perfectly fine with Zack/Seph or Cloud/Seph (though the latter feels wrong without Zack) when it's written by a writer worth their salt. Just thinking a character's badly handled, or uninteresting, or just plain sucky, is no excuse to write them badly or punt them to the corner of the stage, principally in an all-encompassing AU such as this.

I mean, seriously, Reno pisses me off most of the time, but I don't hate him. Hating characters is just plain silly.

[identity profile] bard-linn.livejournal.com 2008-01-28 08:10 pm (UTC)(link)
Yeah, the pit. You should read some - they're FUNNY. I think the most amusing one is the one claiming Zack is 'cheating' on Aeris even thought they broke up....about 5 years ago, story time.

Go figure.

(I know. I see it all the time in high school GAH. I don't need that, thank you!)

I can understand disliking a character. I dislike certain characters (like...Hojo!) but that doesn't mean I'm not going to try and write 'em like they are - or at least try to make them multi-dimensional (as opposed to canon).

[identity profile] elanor-pam.livejournal.com 2008-01-28 09:18 pm (UTC)(link)
What's your FFnet handle? (Or do you have a link in your profile? Maybe I should check)

I don't remember ever feeling passionate enough about a character to hate it. Love a chara? Sure I do, many of them. Hate? Not really. Mostly, I'm indifferent. Even to bad guys; usually, if I feel they're flat, I think of them as mcguffins and go on; if they're awesomely wicked, I'll hate what they do but love how they're done. Like Hojo - as a person, I think he should die in a garbage processing truck, but as a character, I think he works very well and appreciate his existance...

Honestly, I've no idea if what I typed makes sense XD;; sorry for the confusing ideadump.

[identity profile] bard-linn.livejournal.com 2008-01-28 09:25 pm (UTC)(link)
Same thing, but Kiraya's posting. Here's in Kiraya though. XD Here's the review link:
http://www.fanfiction.net/r/2707071/0/1/

[identity profile] elanor-pam.livejournal.com 2008-01-28 11:17 pm (UTC)(link)
...wow. There's some rather special reviews there. I see the one where they bemoan the possibility of Cloud/Tifa, but you forgot to say they'd rather Cloud/Vinny... even though there were no hints and you kept saying they wouldn't ever be going there. Gah.

Zack was acting like a major ass to Cloud, all he cared about was his relationship with Seph.

This person must have been reading a different fic.

And the whole Tifa part was like ugh! So it seems like Cloud is getting the short end of the stick here

...because he's considering Tifa? You'd think she was the worst thing available in the female cast. Seriously, even for Tifa haters, she couldn't possibly be beneath Scarlet.

...if I wrote a review saying "CLOTI 4EVA!!!!", would it generate review wank?

[identity profile] bard-linn.livejournal.com 2008-01-28 11:22 pm (UTC)(link)
Probably not, really.

I know. It's amazing, I've never seen this super special of BE! I think I'm jealous!

[identity profile] arrghigiveup.livejournal.com 2008-01-28 11:40 pm (UTC)(link)
Heh... I'm actually more surprised reading about these reactions than I am by the Zack/Seph, because somehow I'd always felt from way back that it was going to wind up slash eventually. It... kind of shows through? As does the platonic relationship between Cloud and Vincent. Then again, that may just be my inner Cloud/Seph/Zack shipper determinedly putting a spin on everything I read =P

I will admit though, the Cloud/Tifa thing at the end there kind of made me go "Eh?" for a moment there, precisely because I always had various permutations of pairings between Cloud, Seph and Zack in mind when I read this, and never even considered a possible Cloud/Tifa angle.

[identity profile] bard-linn.livejournal.com 2008-01-29 08:12 pm (UTC)(link)
We DID try to hint without putting "AxB"! in the summary.

People are making a big deal out of Cloud-Tifa. I don't see how "Hey, that girl is kind of hot/nice, maybe I should go out with her = One True Luv"

[identity profile] kiraya.livejournal.com 2008-01-29 12:30 am (UTC)(link)
Really, I just think it's silly how we dropped that sledgehammer hint about the Zack/Seph in chapter 30 and we still have people who didn't see it coming.

Then again, though, there was at least that one reviewer at the Pit who deliberately misinterpreted that scene...

(You coming back online?)

[identity profile] alesca-munroe.livejournal.com 2008-01-29 04:23 pm (UTC)(link)
*laughing* I thought everyone knew there would be slash. Vin/Cloud is an amusing thought, but for this story, I agree, the platonic relationship works soooo well.

I thought Cloud was absolutely adorable when he was weighing the pros and cons of maybe trying something beyond friendship with Tifa. Forgot to mention that.

[identity profile] bard-linn.livejournal.com 2008-01-29 08:13 pm (UTC)(link)
We're not that subtle. Kiraya has her preferences listed after all. XD;;

[identity profile] reddesquelle.livejournal.com 2008-01-29 07:42 pm (UTC)(link)
this...I...you...they... ...You do this on purpose, don't you? * sigh * Well, a bisexual Cloud, (if my read on what happened with Reno is correct before Cloud said no[too soon, Reno, timing is everything!!!]) Love this story {just had to say it again} Reviewed the reviews... ... and that's all I have to say about that. I hope Your Evilnesses have mercy on us poor readers {no I don't :)} and leave off with the cliffhangers. Will be rabidly waiting for the next chapter

Redd

[identity profile] bard-linn.livejournal.com 2008-01-29 08:15 pm (UTC)(link)
...do what? That is not a cliff hanger. Every one is alive, not injured and going off to Midgar. o.O I don't get why people are so AHAHAHA!!! CLIFFIE!

Seriously.

(Cloud has, to this point, not consciously been attracted to any men. Reno jumped him and he was NOT interested. Whether things stay that way is a mater of the future)

[identity profile] reddesquelle.livejournal.com 2008-01-29 11:10 pm (UTC)(link)
As regards to the AHAHAHA!!! CLIFFIE! ...the entire emotional inertia of the story did a complete 180 from previous chapters. I guess [ducks head sheepishly] I still felt the "da da da DOOM" from all the previous chapters at the end of this one. >.> <.< my bad [scuttles away]